Reviews of Brown Derby Lunch/Dinner
Read prices, menu items, and more
Menus at Hollywood Brown Derby
Reviewed by Anonymous Review Date: 05/17/2026
Rating: (1) Not Recommended
We decided to try the Brown Derby due to all of the glowing reviews. Therefore we went in with high expectations. What a mistake. It was the most disappointing dining experience we have had at Disney. The hostess was dismissive, almost rude. The server was more interested in catering to the table of eight, while ignoring us, the tee-totaling old couple. After our meal was finished it took alomost a half hour to get the bill. If the food was any good maybe the experience would improve. The chicken was rubbery and the pork was overcooked. This was terribly disappointing, as so many websites give Brown Derby such great reviews. This place must get good reviews, because people think it should be good. We will never go there again. We much prefer the 50's Prime Time where the servers are great and friendly and the food is excellent. We have dined at so many other better locations, California Grill. Liberty Tree Tavern, Via Napoli, Skipper Canteen, Yak and Yets, Chef de France, multiple time, all excellent with friendly caring servers.
Pros:
NoneCons:
Everything, including the priceReviewed by wncmtngirl Review Date: 03/08/2026
Rating: (10) Recommended
We decided to book with the Fantasmic package and glad we did. We had the filet Mignon and it was fantastic! We also ordered the chocolate cake (which we needed a to go box) and the cheesecake and both were delicious. The grapefruit cake martini was good but couldn't drink it all
Pros:
delicious food and great atmosphereCons:
a little noisyReviewed by Anonymous Review Date: 02/16/2026
Rating: (5) Not Recommended
Um, we liked the food a lot better years ago to be honest. They changed the menu and we don't personally really care for it much anymore. The ambience is beautiful with the recreations of the signed works from yesteryear. The servers were wonderful, as for the great most post at Disney. Would be great if they improved on their menu.
Pros:
AmbienceCons:
Food seems to be lacking.Reviewed by mkymouse4ever Review Date: 10/15/2025
Rating: (2) Not Recommended
We have always been a big fan of here. and usually visit it more then once, a trip. But, we are sadly taking this totally off our list. Had a terrible experience here. From our CM waiter to the food. I ordered the pork chop and Ive cooked and seen many pork chops before but, I would not of recognized this as one?? It was round with a ring of fat about 1 1/2 inches around the entire circle. Trying to cut through that was a workout. Thinking this must be something special for the interesting prestation I was wrong the inside was a serious red to pink. Never been served a not cooked piece of pork before? The only thing worse was watching our waiter talk up another waitress at the lil bar for the next half hour > so asking for a refire or something else was off the table. By time he came we just wanted to leave. We did talk to the manager > but I told her I wasn't asking for anything just they need to start cooking the pork properly or people are going to get sick. By far the total worse experience ever at WDW resturants.
Pros:
The AC was niceCons:
Food, staff. EVERYTHINGReviewed by Anonymous Review Date: 04/15/2025
Rating: (6) Not Recommended
I went here back in September 2024, and it was okay. However, the price for the amount of food you get is not great. I got the chorizo-stuffed Chicken Gnocchi, and there were literally only five gnocchis on the plate, and the Chicken only had a little bit of Chorizo in it. I got a drink as well which was good. The theming was cool and I liked all the decor
Pros:
Theming is neat Drinks are niceCons:
Food quality not great Too PriceyReviewed by BrianR Review Date: 01/26/2025
Rating: (9) Recommended
LOVED this place! We went here for my birthday dinner after a full day in the park. They seated us right away once we got the text that we had checked in. We had a really good table (there were only 2 of us) and had plenty of room to eat and spread out, which was nice. Remy (yes, that was his name...fun!!) was our server and he was absolutely fantastic. Checked on us quite often. I had the Filet Mignon and it was wonderful. My wife had the Shepard's Pie and she said it was amazing. We got a dessert and Remy brought out two little flutes of champagne to celebrate my birthday. Just a wonderful experience overall. Atmosphere is great and neat to see all the artistic renderings of the actors/actresses on the wall. I had a manhattan (two actually...hey, it was my birthday) and they were fantastic. Overall, great experience and great dinner.....will definitely be back.
Pros:
Great food, great drinks, great atmosphere. Servers were very friendly and attentive.Cons:
a little pricey; but I felt it was worth it for special occasions.Reviewed by nlg0517 Review Date: 12/07/2024
Rating: (9) Recommended
Let be honest, you’re not coming to the HBD because of its reasonable price point. You coming for the good food in an enjoyable atmosphere without a bunch of kids making noise. The menu has changed since our last visit. They still have the Cobb salad & margarita flight so I was happy. My husband had the salad with chicken. My daughter went with the crab & avocado appetizer- it was also very good. The included bread was hot and tasty. Our waiter was one of the few this trip who provided excellent service. If you’re having a meal in DHS this is the place to go!
Pros:
Food, service & atmosphereCons:
The old menu was betterReviewed by johngalv Review Date: 11/05/2024
Rating: (6) Recommended
Good food with a cool, vintage atmosphere, but not as unique as other Disney fare and very expensive.
Pros:
Quality food and atmosphereCons:
Expensive, food is not unique for price pointReviewed by mschu2112 Review Date: 09/22/2024
Rating: (10) Recommended
Ate here on sept 6th..first time ever.. Food was great, had homemade tomato soup 9excellent) filet mingnion was perfectly cooked, grapefruit cake excellent. Atmosphere and server great.
Pros:
Food, deserts, service. Will be back for sure.Cons:
Not worth a two credit charge on dining plan. But still great meal.Reviewed by DrDeniseRae Review Date: 07/18/2024
Rating: (9) Recommended
As a family of 6 with some picky eaters and a vegetarian, the Brown Derby has managed to be a hit with all family members and is one that we reserve every time we go to Hollywood Studios! Whenever we have friends or other family in tow, we take them here! The servers have always been friendly and helpful.
