Reviews of Liberty Tree Tavern Dinner
Read prices, menu items, and more
Menus at Liberty Tree Tavern
Reviewed by shorebound910 Review Date: 05/07/2014
Rating: (9) Recommended
Liberty Tree is always a reliable. entertaining place to eat. The atmosphere is wonderful, even though I can help nit-picking the authenticity of the "antiques" which makes my wife's eyes roll. Regardless, great food and great theme. I would rank it a ten, but we ate here the day after Garden Grill which has similar food, but does it a little better.
Pros:
Food AtmosphereCons:
NoneReviewed by chrisa Review Date: 04/30/2014
Rating: (10) Recommended
We had never eaten here on our past trips and did so when we were recently there during April break. I was leary because some of the reviews were not good but we loved it and would go back. My favorite was the pork tenderloin. It had the best flavor. I like to eat vegetables on vacation and this offered just that. It is served family style and you can ask for as many refills as you want. I did read one review before we went that said to ask for the Cranberry sauce so we did and my husband loved it. I don't do cranberries but he was pleased. Don't rule this option out if you read a bad review. I never base my decisions on reviews just get a taste for how it may be. I wish the beef was cooked a little longer because we don't like real red beef. I guess that would be my only dislike but it still tasted good.
Pros:
Carved meatCons:
NoneReviewed by pls Review Date: 01/23/2014
Rating: (10) Recommended
My family's tradition is to eat here as our first WDW meal. This year we had a family group of 10, and the family style food was as delicious as ever. There is always plenty. My complaint is that I have always had a long wait to be seated, even with reservations, and there are not enough stalls in the restrooms.
Pros:
delicious buffetCons:
long wait to be seated even with reservationsReviewed by kretzklan Review Date: 01/15/2014
Rating: (8) Recommended
We loved the food here - all so good, fresh and hot. We ate until we nearly burst due to the all you can eat option! Service was a bit slow - but we probably noticed it more because we were trying to get outside to see the Electrical light parade (which is a tip to eat here and be able to get outside - great views of the parade). We didn't enjoy the dessert and that is one of the great things about Disney!
Pros:
Food is awesomeCons:
Dessert is not awesomeReviewed by memakwed Review Date: 12/28/2013
Rating: (8) Recommended
One of our better dinners I think. I like that it is family style so you can sit and eat and relax. Who needs another Disney line while trying to eat. The room was exceedingly loud. Not the restaurants problem, that is purely poor parenting skills at their best. It was such a difference is volume level when that party left. You couldn't even hear people at your table because this family didn't take action with the child causing a raucus. As for the food, the salad was good. Beetter than Garden grill IMO because it was dressed with a raspberry vinaigrette. It was not to light or too heavy. The rolls were yummy. We got more of all the meats potatos and stuffing. the green beans were with garlic and yummy and we finished those. MY mom really enjoyed the turkey fixings just missing cranberry. Here's a tip it turns out if you ask for cranberry they will bring it out. Apparently they throw a lot of rolls and cranberry out so they don't give ample rolls to start and don't hand out cranberry at all but it is there and it is homemade. The dessert was a cranberry cobbler. Plenty to share didn't even finish it. We'll do it next trip. Still miss the characters.
Pros:
family styleCons:
—Reviewed by Imjustababyduck Review Date: 11/25/2013
Rating: (9) Recommended
We ate here on 11/10/13. As always, the food was really, really good (except for dessert). All the food brought to our table of 4 was eaten, and all of it was very, very good for a buffet style of eating. Our server was nice, but a little slow. However, my main complaint was the nasty dessert they are serving now in partnership with Ocean Spray. It is just not good. None of us ate it. We all tried it, but found it to be yucky. It was a rather unhappy ending to an otherwise great meal.
We (have) and will eat here again. It is consistently good, and hopefully they will bring back the apple dessert soon.
Pros:
Good foodCons:
Not so good dessertReviewed by DisneyDork Review Date: 11/11/2013
Rating: (9) Recommended
The turkey was the best I have ever had! We will pobably go back, but won't eat so much salad so I can cram in more turkey, mac & cheese, and mashed potatoes! Delicious!
Pros:
Delicious food, nice atmosphereCons:
we ate too much!Reviewed by pop2 Review Date: 10/05/2013
Rating: (8) Recommended
Just got back Sept 28th from Disney. This was our second time eating at Liberty Tree. We were on the Disney dining plan so we used a table credit. Good use of table credit in our opinion. Everyone had plenty to eat and it was delicious. We were almost an hour late to our reservation, but they accommodated us and got us in fairly quickly (about 20 min.) Again the food was great. It was great to have vegetables after eating park food all week. We were very happy with all the food. It tastes like home cooking with mashed potatoes, gravy, turkey, mac and cheese and wonderful garlic green beans. One of the best meals we had all week. Service was weak. Service had very little personality and didn't even greet us when he came to the table. Food took longer than expected , but was good. We would go back despite our unfriendly waiter.
Pros:
foodCons:
service, priceReviewed by chlobug26 Review Date: 09/21/2013
Rating: (7) Recommended
I would like to give this place an eight, but I cant. Our server ran around like a crazy man, taking care of numerous tables, so we didn't get many refills. Plus, the food took a while to come out. Food itself was pretty good. The turkey was moist. Colonial theming was nice. Disney really needs more servers during the free dining program.
Pros:
FoodCons:
Seemed super understaffed. Not the best service.Reviewed by mawdryn Review Date: 07/09/2013
Rating: (9) Recommended
My family of 6 along with my visiting sister dined here on July 3rd. We had 5:30 reservations, and showed up about 15 minutes late, because the It's a Small World's line ran a little longer than expected. That being said, we were seated right away.
Our waitress took our drink orders after we sat down and delivered 2 bowls of salad and a basket of bread soon after. The rest of the bounty just kept coming, and asking for more was never an issue.
The food was all hot and tasty. I do miss the cobbler though. It was replaced with some sort of cake that was just all right.
I didn't give this restaurant a 10, because our waitress was not very friendly and she made a mistake with our dining plan.
I have dined here at least 4 or 5 times in the past and have always enjoyed it. I do miss the characters!!!!!
