REVIEW! We Tried SO MANY Treats from the Newly Opened Gideon’s Bakehouse in Disney Springs!

Gideon’s Bakehouse has FINALLY opened in Disney Springs, and we can’t help but want to eat a whole bunch of goodies from the bakery.

Gideon’s Bakehouse

And, we’re taking you with us to check out everything happening over at the bakery as we snack our way through a few treats!

When guests first arrived to Gideon’s today the store was using a virtual waiting list to enter the restaurant, which was at about a 3-hour wait when we joined midday.

Virtual Waitlist

After we were called, we returned back to the queue to enter the bakery…

Virtual Waitlist Queue

…as guests were given a Gideon’s menu to check out all the treats available inside!

Gideon’s Menu

Along with the handmade cookies, there are also cake slices and nitro cold brew on tap.

Gideon’s Menu

Of course, we had to snag a whole lot of cookies and a cold brew to wash them all down during our first visit!

Gideon’s Treats

Original Chocolate Chip Cookie

When Disney World originally had Gideon’s cookies placed in the Polite Pig, we indulged in the amazing Original Chocolate Chip Cookie.

Original Chocolate Chip

The 1/2 pound treat is made with a buttery dough with SO MANY chocolate chips and a kick of real vanilla bean. And, it’s got a million chocolate chips so you can enjoy all the chocolate-y goodness in each bite!

Chocolate Chip Cookie

Cookies and Cream Cookie

We’re calling all Oreo lovers because the Cookies and Cream Cookie was WAY too good to pass up.

Cookies and Cream Cookie

The soft vanilla cookie is made with chunks of Double Stuff Oreos with even more Oreos crushed on the outside. Honestly, if you can only imagine the best Oreo ever combined with lots of soft cookie dough, the Cookies and Cream Cookie is even better than that.

Cookies and Cream Cookie

Peanut Butter Crunch Cookie

While there’s been plenty of chocolate in this review, we also had the Peanut Butter Crunch Cookie, which is a cookie heavy on peanut butter and handmade candied peanuts.

Peanut Butter Crunch Cookie

Peanut butter fans, you’re going to want to hurry to Gideon’s because this might be one of our favorite treats EVER, especially with that little salt finish.

Peanut Butter Crunch Cookie

Coffee Cake Cookie

You can even check out the extra buttery Coffee Cake Cookie with vanilla bean cookie filled with cinnamon strudel and topped with homemade double baked butter crumbs.

Coffee Cake Cookie

The Coffee Cake Cookie has a gooey cinnamon layer on the bottom that REALLY makes us want to stuff a bunch of these in our freezers.

Coffee Cake Cookie

Santa’s White Christmas Cookie

Just in time for Christmas, you can find a few holiday goodies at Gideon’s! Santa’s White Christmas Cookie is a white chocolate chip cookie with coconut, caramel, vanilla, nutty flavors, and freshly-ground and locally roasted coffee beans.

Santa’s White Christmas Cookie

On top of the cookie, you can finish things off on a sweet note with sugar, sea salt, and Christmas glitter. Coffee lovers, you’ll be happy to know that you can VERY much taste the coffee! (And, it’s mega glittery, so that’s only a plus.)

Santa’s White Christmas Cookie

Cookie Vom Krampus

But, if you’re looking for something a little more minty, you can find the Cookie Vom Krampus instead with a triple-chocolate velvet-textured cookie filled with Andes mint.

Cookie Van Krampus

Each of the cookies only cost $6 so you can have a cookie that’s both GIANT and delicious! Don’t worry, though! We’ll be back to try even MORE goodies at Gideon’s Bakehouse soon. And, we’ll give you a look at all the other treats around Disney World throughout the holiday season.

Here’s the new Whiskey Corkcicle you can grab at Wine Bar George in Disney Springs!

What’s your favorite cookie to grab at Gideon’s? Let us know in the comments below!

Rachel Franko has been going to Disney Parks since she was a baby, and her love of Disney has only grown into a SLIGHT obsession since! She's been writing for AllEars since 2019 and loves sharing the magic with all the readers. When she's not writing, you can catch her heading to Disney and Universal Studios with a heart full of dreams and a backpack full of themed ears!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

2 Replies to “REVIEW! We Tried SO MANY Treats from the Newly Opened Gideon’s Bakehouse in Disney Springs!”

    1. Yeah, that’s a lot and I know the GMC commercial Mike means. It would be hard for a family to afford the cookies, but maybe they could split them.