Reviews of Erin McKenna’s Bakery
Read prices, menu items, and more
Menus at Erin Mckenna's Bakery NYC
Reviewed by Anonymous Review Date: 03/09/2025
Rating: (1) Not Recommended
Worst bakery ever
Pros:
leaving the store and going to sprinklesCons:
Walking in the doorReviewed by Anonymous Review Date: 06/19/2023
Rating: (1) Not Recommended
My wife bought 4 bagels recently. The next morning we discovered they were so stale they crumbled, couldn't be sliced, tasted stale, and left a strange after-taste. We threw out the two we tried, and decided to return the other two the following day when we planned to dine in the area. The two worker's advised my wife the owner refused to allow them to take returns, to come back the next day. When she returned to me, as I waited in the car, she explained the above. I returned, and got the same nonsense. I advised the workers we would not be inconvenienced further, that they needed to call the manager/owner to either refund or exchange. The employee advised he contacted the owner, and she asked that pictures be taken of the stale items, and we could discuss it another day. I left the box on the counter, suggested the owner eat some of her own, stale bagels, and see if she becomes as ill as we felt the previous morning. This should have been resolved with an apology, and exchange or refund. Instead, I am writing this review, and will be contacting our credit card company to advise we did not get the benefit of our bargain, when the bakery served stale merchandise, and the owner refused any reasonable resolution. Ask the owner what she does if her product is not eatable. I suppose it is caveat emptor, buyer be wear.
Pros:
see reviewCons:
see reviewReviewed by Anonymous Review Date: 09/20/2021
Rating: (1) Not Recommended
Birthday Carrot Cake, very disappointing!
Pros:
NoneCons:
Cake Extremely dry, got stuck in our throats. Ruined the birthday celebration, we threw it out.Reviewed by Anonymous Review Date: 06/13/2021
Rating: (1) Not Recommended
Very low quality. The bakery is an anomaly in Disney Springs. Typically in Disney Springs employees are very friendly and the quality of goods is high.
Here, the baked goods we purchased were stale, the employees were not customer focused and the baked goods we got were packaged poorly.
We spent 5 days in Disney World, this was by far the worst experience of the trip.
Pros:
They have air conditioningCons:
Food is stale. Employees were not quite rude, but certainly did not know how to treat customers. Cost is pretty high when you consider what you are getting. Goods were not packaged with care.Reviewed by Anonymous Review Date: 01/19/2021
Rating: (10) Recommended
Gluten free sweets are great and prices are very reasonable
Pros:
GreatCons:
NoneReviewed by AmberMac Review Date: 02/06/2020
Rating: (10) Recommended
This is one of my son’s favorite parts about our trips. Because he is gluten-free and dairy free, when we walk in here I tell him he can get anything he wants. Obviously he would love to get one of everything, but he usually picks a cupcake. He’s always satisfied. My husband is also gluten-free and will get hey cupcake or “ice cream”.
Pros:
Absolute heaven for people with food allergies or vegan dietsCons:
If you aren’t used to eating vegan and gluten-free, the treats may not be as tasty to youReviewed by hsmamato2 Review Date: 04/18/2019
Rating: (9) Recommended
I like it here...when on a restricted diet, it can be tough to find yummy options- this place offers so many good choices! (Samoa donut!) And without the guilt of going off your diet...
Pros:
Great treats for special diets,or anyoneCons:
not every item is great, but most are quite good.Reviewed by HunterBill Review Date: 01/28/2019
Rating: (9) Recommended
This place was a lifesaver. After many days of lackluster GF snacks at the parks, we discovered Erin McKenna's. Keeping in mind that it is very difficult to duplicate baked goods without gluten, the quality and variety of this store was exceptional. We ventured back to DS three times just for my daughter to come here.
Pros:
Excellent GF optionsCons:
We got lost all three times we tried to come here, but hat may be on meReviewed by Thea Review Date: 09/27/2018
Rating: (3) Not Recommended
The bakery had come highly recommended. We tried the banana teacake, a vanilla cupcake and a salted caramel doughnut was almost flavorless and gluey in consistency. The caramel drizzle was very thin. The cupcake was also not very flavorful. The teacake was okay, but needed more banana flavor. Too expensive for the quality and taste of the products.
Pros:
NoneCons:
ExpensiveReviewed by DeanMoriarity Review Date: 02/26/2018
Rating: (10) Recommended
As a vegan I find it difficult to find good food while traveling. I do my homework and search out vegan options & will go out of my way to patronize a vegan establishment. Like any other type of restaurant it can be hit or miss on the quality.
Erin McKenna’s Bakery is a hit. Cupcakes, doughnuts, cookies and milkshakes. All are top quality vegan goods. For those that are vegan or have an egg/dairy allergy and still want to satisfy their sweet tooth this is the place to be. I’ll stop by every time I go to Disney Springs.
