Olivia’s Cafe 2025 Dinner Menu and Prices

Restaurants in Walt Disney World Menus in Walt Disney World
Last Updated: March 2024

Walt Disney World > Disney Resorts > Old Key West > Olivia's Cafe


See All Food Photos

Reader Reviews:

Rating

8.03 / 10

Recommended By

83%
Read all 30 Reviews
Post a new Review

Discounts Available:

Disney Rewards VISA 10%
Disney Vacation Club 10%
Annual Passholder 10%

Disney Dining Plan:

Table Service Meal (2025)
Table Service To Go (1 table service meal) (2025)
Show All Food Photos Recent Changes
Get Notified!

Dessert

Olivia's Bananas Foster Warm Banana Bread, Bananas Foster Sauce, and Vanilla Ice Cream $9.00
Key Lime Pie Traditional Key Lime Pie $9.00
Chocolate Fudge Brownie with Chocolate Ganache, Dehydrated Strawberries, Mixed Berries, and a Berry Sauce $9.00
Flan Classic Caramel Flan $10.00

Appetizers/Starters

Homemade Soup of the Day ask your server for details $10
Conch Chowder Manhatten-style served with oyster crackers $9.25
Crab Cake, Pan-seared and served with Jalapeño Aïoli, Grilled Pineapple Salsa, and Chayote Slaw $15
Shrimp Cocktail Jumbo Shrimp, Key West Cocktail Sauce, Tropical Slaw, and Citrus $16
Soup of the Day $10
Savory Hushpuppies Olivia’s Famous Recipe served with Key Lime Mustard $12
Beer-braised Mussels Local Florida Ale, Jalapeño, and Grilled Crostini $18

Soup/Salad

Seasonal Market Salad Mixed Greens, Quinoa, Avocado, Edamame, Orange, and Key Lime Vinaigrette $12

Entrees

Southernmost Buttermilk Chicken, Mashed Potatoes, Southern Gravy, Biscuit and Seasonal Vegetables $25
Grilled New York Strip served with parmesan-roasted fingerling potatoes, seasonal vegetables and herb chimichurri $34
Slow-Cooked Prime Rib Roasted Garlic Mashed Potatoes and Broccolini $37
Plantation Key Pork Chop, brined bone-in pork chop glazed with an apple-white balsamic gastrique severed with sweet potatoes, apples, onions, arugula, cranberries, and apple vinaigrette garnished with candied nuts $25
Captain Wahoo's Catch of the Day Ask your server for today's catch $Market Price
Tortuga Seafood Stew shrimp, scallop, calamari, mahi mahi, and mussels simmering in a coconut and tomato broth with garbanzo beans, pineapple, and edamame served with lime rice and toasted almonds $26
Mojo-brined Pork Butter-poached Potatoes, Savory Purée, and Mustard Gastrique $29
Mahi Mahi Mahi Mahi with Fingerling Potatoes, Corn Succotash, Chorizo, Citrus Butter, and Corn Silk $30
Shrimp Scampi Jumbo Shrimp, Linguine, Tomato, Scallions, and Citrus Butter Sauce $29
Signature Bacon Cheeseburger Cheddar, Crispy Onions, Avocado, and Bacon Jam with House-made Key West Ketchup and Aïoli $24.00

Plant-based

West Indian Tofu and Coconut Curry Mango-Coconut Curry, Crisp Vegetables, Jasmine Rice, and Cilantro $23

Beverages

Soft Drinks Coke, diet Coke, Coke Zero, Sprite, Root beer, Pibb Xtra, Light Pomegranate Lemonade $4.79
Iced Tea $4.79
Hot Tea

Coffees

Coffee $3.99
Espresso $3.69
Cappuccino or Latte, $4.39
Cafe Mocha $4.69
Frozen Cappuccino $5.50
French Press Pot Alto Mayo Protected Forest Coffee roasted by Joffrey's coffee, serves two $9.25

Specialty Beverages (non-alcoholic)

Milk Shakes chocolate, vanilla, or strawberry $7
Agave Garden, Lyre’s Agave Reserva Spirit, Cold-pressed Lime Juice, Passionfruit Papaya Green Tea, and Cucumber $12.50
Pink Spritzer, Lyre’s Pink London Spirit, Grapefruit Soda, Pomegranate Green Tea, Lime and Mint $12.50

Specialty Cocktails

Captain's Mai Tai Captain Morgan Original Spiced Rum, Bols Amaretto, and Tropical Juices topped with a float of Myer’s Original Dark Rum $15
Turtle Krawl Coconut Rum, Spiced Rum, White Rum, Pineapple, Orange, and Key Lime Juices $15
Rum Runner Plantation Dark Rum, Creme de Banana, Blackberry Brandy, and Orange and Pineapple Juices with a float of Gosling's 151 Rum $16
Olivia's Strawberry Lemonade Patrón Silver Tequila, Key Lime Juice, Strawberry, and Lemonade with a Sugared Rim $16.00
Papa's Den Jack Daniel's, Peach Schnapps, Cherry Brandy, Orange Juice, Pineapple Juice, and Grenadine $13.00
Blood Orange Margarita Lunazul Añejo Tequila, Cointreau Liqueur, Lime Juice, and Blood Orange Sour $16
Spicy Poblano Margarita Patrón Silver Tequila, Ancho Reyes Verde Liqueur, Lime Juice, and Pure Cane Sugar $17
Paloma Corazon Blanco Tequila with juices of Ruby Red Grapefruit and Lime topped with Soda Water $16
Rum Swizzle Mount Gay Eclipse Rum with Tropical Juices and flavors of Guava and Mango $15
Raspberry Mojito Bacardi Raspberry Rum, Mount Gay Eclipse Rum, Lime Juice, Mint, and Raspberry Purée topped with Soda Water $15
Antioxidant Lemonade Van Gogh Açaí-Blueberry Vodka, Lemonade, and Pomegranate Juice topped with Sprite $14.50
Walk the Plank Old Forester Bourbon, Orange Juice, Orgeat (Almond), and Lemon Juice garnished with Luxardo Gourmet Maraschino Cherries $17
Smoked Turkey Wild Turkey 101 Bourbon, Red Stag Black Cherry Bourbon, Grenadine, and Lemonade with a hint of Hickory Smoke, garnished with Luxardo Gourmet Maraschino Cherries $17
Whiskey Breeze Old Forester Bourbon, Cointreau, and Lime Juice with flavors of Guava and Mango $17
Kentucky Mule Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon, Lime Juice, and Pure Cane Sugar topped with Fever Tree Ginger Beer $16.50
Bahama Mama Parrot Bay Coconut Rum, Plantation Original Dark Rum, Bols Crème de Banana, and Tropical Juices $15
Piña CoLava Bacardi Raspberry Rum blended with flavors of Coconut, Pineapple, and Raspberry Purée $16
Irish Coffee with Jameson Irish Whiskey $13.50
Jamaican Coffee with Tia Maria Coffee Liqueur and Plantation Original Dark Rum $12
Keoke Coffee with Kahlúa, EandJ Brandy, and Bols Dark Creme de Cacao $13.50
Bourbon Berry Lemonade Woodford Reserve Bourbon, Bols Blackberry Brandy, and Premium Lemonade with a splash of Soda Water $16
Key West Freeze WÓDKA Vodka and Bols Melon Liqueur blended with flavors of Coconut, Pineapple, and Strawberry $15
Bacardi Mojito Bacardi Superior Rum, Lime Juice, Pure Cane Sugar, and Mint topped with Soda Water $15
Piña Colada SelvaRey Coconut Rum, Pineapple, Agave, and Orange Bitters served over Ice $17
Sparkling Hibiscus Helix7 Vodka, Sorel Liqueur, Lemon, Honey, and Grapefruit Soda $17.50
Sunset Margarita Teremana Blano Tequila, Grand Marnier Liqueur, Smoked Chili Bitters, Lime, and Agave $17.00
Indigo Hibiscus Empress 1908 Gin, Bols Blue Curacao Liqueur, Minute Maid® Premium Lemonade, Orgeat (Almond), Lemon, and Hibiscus Grenadine $16.50
Cold Brew Martini SelvaRey Chocolate Rum, Tia Maria Liqueur, and Joffrey’s Coffee™ Cold Brew $16.50

Beer

Beer bottled, canned, draft $8.50-$12.75

Wine

Sparkling Wine by the glass $9; by the bottle $39
Assorted White Wines by the glass $9 - $11; by the bottle $39 - $49
Assorted Red Wines by the glass $9 - $13; by the bottle $39 - $55
Sangria Opici red or white, by the glass $13

Cider

Angry Orchard Crisp Apple Hard Cider

Other Menus at Olivia's Cafe

Lunch Menu

Cuisines: American

Breakfast Menu

Cuisines: American

Children's Brunch Menu

Cuisines: American

Children's Dinner Menu

Cuisines: American

Brunch Menu

Cuisines: American

Find more Dining Locations and Menus