It’s been quite the horror-filled Halloween already as tricks and treats pop up all around Universal Orlando!

We’ve gone on Scarecrow Stalks, faced our fears at the two daytime houses, and (of course) eaten as many Halloween Horror Nights snacks as possible. While Twisted Taters and Pizza Fries have returned to Universal, the Tribute Store has been serving up ghoulish delights that fans won’t want to miss out on during their visits!
Since the Bride of Frankenstein and the Tooth Fairy have become the icons of the Halloween Horror Nights houses this year, the Tribute Store has fashioned a few new goodies based on the characters! You can pick up the sweet new Bride of Frankenstein Cupcake…

…but we were a little more interested in the monstrosity that is the Stolen Teeth Tart!

Since the Tooth Fairy enacts revenge on anyone who won’t hand over their teeth, it looks like this tart might have some of those stolen molars (in fondant form, obviously ?) decorating it.

While the Stolen Teeth Tart definitely looks scary, it’s actually SO good! The strawberry and chocolate on the tart complement each other. The cookie part is soft and sweet with each bite, even though there is a slight crunch that we love!

We guess the Tooth Fairy’s revenge was worth it since this new Halloween Horror Nights treat is an absolute hit with us, teeth and all!

Although we loved the Stolen Teeth Tart, there are so many other Halloween goodies around the parks that are must-haves for spooky season! As Universal Orlando continues to release even more merchandise and snacks for the modified event, we’ll give you a first look at all the frightful fun happening in the parks!
Take a look at the AWESOME throwback face masks we found in Universal today!
What’s your favorite Halloween treat so far in the theme parks this year? Let us know in the comments below!
Universal Orlando
- NEW Report Shows Theme Park Ride Injuries So Far in 2026
- 7 Perks Announced for Universal Orlando Annual Passholders
- You Can Get FREE Tickets to Universal Orlando — But There’s a Catch!
- This Is The Most Florida Souvenir You Can Find At Universal Orlando
- Wait. Is Universal Hiring For Your DREAM JOB?
- Everyone Complains About the Harry Potter Ride, But They’re Forgetting THIS Tricky Epic Universe Attraction
- Two Universals, Two Very Different Trips: Orlando vs. Singapore
- NEWS: Universal Orlando Introduces NEW Skip-The-Line Pass
- The NEW Ride Strategy You Need for Epic Universe Since Early Park Admission CHANGED
- We’ve Waited SO LONG for the Return of This Secret Universal Orlando Experience
Join the AllEars.net Newsletter to stay on top of ALL the breaking Disney News! You'll also get access to AllEars tips, reviews, trivia, and MORE! Click here to Subscribe!

Trending Now
This new rule can make Disney World Annual Passes harder to get!
You can't miss this new HOKA drop!
Don't make these mistakes.
Orlando International Airport has new nonstop flights this month.
When traveling to Disney World, you'll want to remember these five laws that you could...
These are 9 new bags online that are great to carry around the Disney parks.
Grab these Disney items on sale at Amazon NOW.
You won't believe the ride with the most injuries so far in 2026.
Thinking of grabbing your mom a new Disney Loungefly bag for Mother's Day? Check out...
If you've been hunting for your first Loungefly (or more) to add to your collection...
Walt Disney Imagineering's new patent will cut wait times in half!
There's a NEW drink at The Cake Bake Shop, and YES, we're just as obsessed...
The fan-favorite location is turning into something new, and likely bringing an old favorite with...
The popular store is one of several changes coming to CityWalk.
We are in Disney World every day -- these are our must-have items in our...
Disney World ride closures just happen.
V.I.PASSHOLDER Days Start Next Week On May 1st, And Passholders Are Getting Some AMAZING Offerings!
A new pool opened up in Disney World this week...but there are still dozens of...
The latest MagicBand designs to hit Disney World!
Want to watch 'Star Wars' in chronological order? Start here!