Olivia's Cafe 2020 Dinner Menu and Prices

Appetizers/Starters

Crab Cake pan-fried and served with avocado puree, house-made roasted pepper remoulade sauce, and chayote salad $13

Conch Chowder Manhatten-style served with oyster crackers $10

Conch Fritters with Key Lime-Mustard and Roasted Pepper Remoulade $12

Homemade Soup of the Day ask your server for details $8

Tomato-Mozzarella Salad cherry tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and orange segments with mixed greens, ciabatta crostini, and balsamic glaze $11

Caesar Salad chopped romaine lettuce tossed with parmesan, homemade croutons, and caesar dressing; add chicken for $6; $9

Entrees

Grilled New York Strip served with parmesan-roasted fingerling potatoes, seasonal vegetables and herb chimichurri $34

Tortuga Seafood Stew shrimp, scallop, calamari, mahi mahi, and mussels simmering in a coconut and tomato broth with garbanzo beans, pineapple, and edamame served with lime rice and toasted almonds $26

Southernmost Buttermilk Chicken, mashed potatoes, southern gravy, and seasonal vegetables $21

Seven Mile Sea Scallops pan-seared scallops over soft polenta topped with edamame-pancetta succotash and tomato vinaigrette $27

Plantation Key Pork Chop, brined bone-in pork chop glazed with an apple-white balsamic gastrique severed with sweet potatoes, apples, onions, arugula, cranberries, and apple vinaigrette garnished with candied nuts $25

Slow-Cooked Prime Rib 10-oz cut with Olivia's potatoes, seasonal vegetables and cabernet demi-glace $37

Fish of the Day crab-crusted mahi mahi served with a tropical couscous, avocado-pico de gallo, and mango butter sauce $Market Price

Cayo Hueso Shrimp Pasta sauteed shrimp, zucchini, yellow squash, grape tomato, and spinach tossed wtih penne pasta and pesto cream sauce $24

Plant-based

Tropical Chocolate Tart Avocado-Chocolate Ganache with a Mango-Lime Sorbet garnished with a Toasted Coconut Crumble $8.00

Beets and Citrus Salad

West Indian Tofu and Coconut Curry

Desserts

Mascarpone Cheesecake with Seasonal Fruit $8.50

Flourless Chocolate Cake with fresh seasonal berries $8.50

Key Lime Tart, with mango and raspberry sauce $7

Banana Bread Pudding Sundae, served warm with Bananas Foster topping and Vanilla Bean Ice Cream $7

Mile Marker Zero No Sugar Added Tropical Panna Cotta $8.50

Beverages

Soft Drinks Coke, diet Coke, Coke Zero, Sprite, Root beer, Pibb Xtra, Light Pomegranate Lemonade $3.19

Iced Tea $3.19

Hot Tea

Coffees

French Press Pot Alto Mayo Protected Forest Coffee roasted by Joffrey's coffee, serves two $9.00

Coffee

Espresso $3.69

Cappuccino or Latte, $4.39

Cafe Mocha $4.69

Frozen Cappuccino $5.50

Specialty Beverages (non-alcoholic)

Milk Shakes chocolate, vanilla, or strawberry $7

Specialty Cocktails

Captain's Mai Tai Captain Morgan Original Spiced rum, Amaretto, and tropical juices topped with a float of Plantation dark rum $13.00

Turtle Krawl Coconut Rum, Spiced Rum, White Rum, Pineapple, Orange, and Key Lime Juices $13.00

Rum Runner Plantation Dark Rum, Creme de Banana, Blackberry Brandy, and Orange and Pineapple Juices with a float of Gosling's 151 Rum $13.00

Godiva Chocolate Martini Godiva chocolate liqueur, Stoli vanil vodka, white creme de cacao, and frangelico $12.50

Key Lime Pie Martini Stoli vanil vodka, LICOR 43, lime juice, and vanilla ice cream $12.50

Irish Coffee with Jameson Irish whiskey $12.00

Jamaican Coffee with Tia Maria Coffee Liqueur and Plantation Original Dark Rum $12.00

Keoke Coffee with Kahlúa, EandJ Brandy, and Bols Dark Creme de Cacao $12.00

Olivia's Strawberry Lemonade Patrón Silver Tequila, Key Lime Juice, Strawberry, and Odwalla Lemonade with a Sugared Rim $15.00

Papa's Den Jack Daniel's, Peach Schnapps, Cherry Brandy, Orange Juice, Pineapple Juice, and Grenadine $13.00

Cold Brew XO Patrón XO Cafe Coffee Liqueur, Heavy Cream, and Cold Brew Joffrey's Coffee $13.00

Beer

Key West Sunset Ale draft $6.75

Yeungling Lager draft $6.75

Samuel Adams Seasonal draft $6.75

Bud Light draft $6.00

Import/Specialty Bottled Beer Corona or Blue Moon $6.50

Premium Bottled Beer New Belgium Fat Tire, New Belgium Ranger, Key West Southernmost Wheat, 7 Mile IPA, Schofferhoffer Hefeweizen, Stella Artois, Angry Orchard Crisp Apple Hard Cider or Guinness Stout $7.50-$8.75

Wine

Assorted White Wines by the glass $9 - $11; by the bottle $39 - $49

Assorted Red Wines by the glass $9 - $13; by the bottle $39 - $55

Sparkling Wine by the glass $9; by the bottle $39

Sangria Beso del Sol red or white, by the glass $10.00

Pitcher of Sangria your choice of red or white sangria served with freshly sliced fruit $30

Other Menus at Olivia's Cafe Dining Location

Find more Dining Locations and Menus