Recent Menu Changes to ’50s Prime Time Cafe

Sunday, March 1st 2026 changes to '50s Prime Time Cafe Lunch/Dinner Menu

A Sampling of Mom's Favorite Recipescostchanged from 32to 34
Floats costchanged from 7.75to 8
Aunt Liz's Golden Fried Chicken costchanged from 27to 29
Cousin Megan's Traditional Meatloaf costchanged from 25to 26
Patron Platinum Margaritacostchanged from 17.50to 18.50
Ultimate Long Island Iced Teacostchanged from 17.50to 18.50
Dad's Electric Lemonadecostchanged from 17.50to 18.50
Grandma's Picnic Punchcostchanged from 17.50to 18.50
Grandpa Jean’s Chicken Pot Piecostchanged from 25to 26
The Tune-In PBJ Cocktailcostchanged from 16.50to 17.50
Beercostchanged from 8.75-$13.25to 9.75-$13.25
Cornbread Skilletcostchanged from 10to 11
Removed Pomegranate Lemonadefrom Menu Items
Removed Chocolate Martinifrom Menu Items
Removed Fireball Cocktailfrom Menu Items
Removed Grasshopper Barfrom Menu Items
Removed Indigo Hibiscusfrom Menu Items
Added Pink Spritzerto Menu Items
Added Island Fusion Punchto Menu Items
Added Toasted Marshmallow Old Fashionedto Menu Items
Added Espresso Martinito Menu Items
Added Coconut Gimletto Menu Items
Added Specialty Beverages (non-alcoholic)to Pink SpritzerMenu Categories
Added Specialty Cocktailsto Island Fusion PunchMenu Categories
Added Specialty Cocktailsto Toasted Marshmallow Old FashionedMenu Categories
Added Specialty Cocktailsto Espresso MartiniMenu Categories
Added Specialty Cocktailsto Coconut GimletMenu Categories

Friday, September 19th 2025 changes to '50s Prime Time Cafe Lunch/Dinner Menu

Added to Image Types
Added Neapolitan Barto Menu Items
Added to Image Types
Added Cornbread Skilletto Menu Items
Added to Image Types
Added A Sampling of Mom's Favorite Recipesto Menu Items

Tuesday, July 15th 2025 changes to '50s Prime Time Cafe Children's Lunch/Dinner Menu

Stained Glass Dessertcostchanged from 3.00to
Removed Garden Saladfrom Menu Items
Removed Creamy Tomato Soupfrom Menu Items
Added Garden Saladto Menu Items
Added Corn Chowderto Menu Items
Added Appetizers/Startersto Garden SaladMenu Categories
Added Appetizers/Startersto Corn ChowderMenu Categories

Tuesday, July 15th 2025 changes to '50s Prime Time Cafe Lunch/Dinner Menu

Shrimp Cocktailnamechanged from Griddled Salmon Caketo Shrimp Cocktail
Shrimp Cocktaildescriptionchanged from Served with Succotash and Dill Sour Creamto Served with Kale Salad and Cocktail Sauce
Key Lime Barnamechanged from Key Lime Pieto Key Lime Bar
Key Lime Bardescriptionchanged from Topped with Whipped Cream and served with a Raspberry Sauceto Tart Key Lime Filling over a Buttery Sugar Crust served with Raspberries and Raspberry Sauce
Removed Roasted Tomato Soupfrom Menu Items
Removed Hummingbird Bundt Cakefrom Menu Items
Added Cousin Bob's Seasonal Chowderto Menu Items
Added Neapolitan Barto Menu Items
Added Appetizers/Startersto Cousin Bob's Seasonal ChowderMenu Categories
Added Dessertto Neapolitan BarMenu Categories

Friday, July 26th 2024 changes to '50s Prime Time Cafe Children's Lunch/Dinner Menu

Grandma's Macaroni & Cheesecostchanged from 10to
Goofy's Salmoncostchanged from 14.5to 13.50
Removed For Children Ages 3-9from Aunt Betty's Chicken StripsMenu Categories
Added Kids' Entréesto Aunt Betty's Chicken StripsMenu Categories
Removed For Children Ages 3-9from Grandma's Macaroni & CheeseMenu Categories
Added Side Dishesto Grandma's Macaroni & CheeseMenu Categories
Removed Mickey Check Mealsfrom Grandpa's Grilled ChickenMenu Categories
Added Kids' Entréesto Grandpa's Grilled ChickenMenu Categories
Removed Mickey Check Mealsfrom Goofy's SalmonMenu Categories
Added Kids' Entréesto Goofy's SalmonMenu Categories
Removed For Children Ages 3-9from Sloppy Joe SandwichMenu Categories
Added Kids' Entréesto Sloppy Joe SandwichMenu Categories

Friday, July 26th 2024 changes to '50s Prime Time Cafe Lunch/Dinner Menu

Angry Orchard Crisp Apple Hard Cidercostchanged from 9.25to 10
Removed Chicken Noodle Soupfrom Menu Items
Removed Ice Cream Sundaesfrom Menu Items
Removed Mom's Browniefrom Menu Items
Removed Angry Orchard Crisp Apple Hard Ciderfrom Menu Items
Removed 2022 THANKSGIVING- Holiday Plate- Avail 11/24from Menu Items
Removed 2022 HOLIDAY- In Holiday Fashionfrom Menu Items
Removed 2023 Celebrate Soulfully- Shrimp & Gritsfrom Menu Items
Removed White Claw Black Cherry Hard Seltzerfrom Menu Items

Wednesday, July 17th 2024 changes to '50s Prime Time Cafe Lunch/Dinner Menu

Traditional Warm Apple Crisp A la Modenamechanged from Traditional Warm Apple Crispto Traditional Warm Apple Crisp A la Mode
Traditional Warm Apple Crisp A la Modedescriptionchanged from $2 additional for A la modeto
Traditional Warm Apple Crisp A la Modecostchanged from 8to 10

Sunday, June 16th 2024 changes to '50s Prime Time Cafe Lunch/Dinner Menu

Sangriacostchanged from 12.00to 15.00

Wednesday, April 10th 2024 changes to '50s Prime Time Cafe Lunch/Dinner Menu

Cousin Amy's Romaine Wedge Saladdescriptionchanged from Marinated Tomatoes, Blue Cheese Crumbles, and Roasted Red Pepper Ranch Dressing (Plant-based)to Marinated Tomatoes, Blue Cheese Crumbles, and Roasted Red Pepper Ranch Dressing

Sunday, April 7th 2024 changes to '50s Prime Time Cafe Lunch/Dinner Menu

Cousin Amy's Romaine Wedge Saladnamechanged from Cousin Amy's Iceberg Lettuce Wedgeto Cousin Amy's Romaine Wedge Salad
Cousin Amy's Romaine Wedge Saladdescriptionchanged from Plant-based Ranch Dressing, Rice Paper Bacon, Chives, Cherry Tomatoes, Sliced Red Onionsto Marinated Tomatoes, Blue Cheese Crumbles, and Roasted Red Pepper Ranch Dressing (Plant-based)
Removed Cousin Harold's Vegetable Gardenfrom Menu Items
Removed Fried Herb and Garlic Cheesefrom Menu Items
Removed Pineapple Upside-Down Cakefrom Menu Items
Removed Lemon Meringue Piefrom Menu Items
Removed Deviled Eggsfrom Menu Items
Added Caesar Saladto Menu Items
Added Cornbread Skilletto Menu Items
Added Griddled Salmon Caketo Menu Items
Added Cousin Harold's Rigatoni Pastato Menu Items
Added 50’s Prime Time Café Blue Plate Specialto Menu Items
Added Hummingbird Bundt Caketo Menu Items
Added Key Lime Pieto Menu Items
Added Entreesto Caesar SaladMenu Categories
Added Appetizers/Startersto Cornbread SkilletMenu Categories
Added Appetizers/Startersto Griddled Salmon CakeMenu Categories
Added Entreesto Cousin Harold's Rigatoni PastaMenu Categories
Added Vegetarianto Cousin Harold's Rigatoni PastaFlags
Added Entreesto 50’s Prime Time Café Blue Plate SpecialMenu Categories
Added Dessertto Hummingbird Bundt CakeMenu Categories
Added Dessertto Key Lime PieMenu Categories

Tuesday, February 6th 2024 changes to '50s Prime Time Cafe Lunch/Dinner Menu

Added White Claw Black Cherry Hard Seltzerto Menu Items
Added Specialty Cocktailsto White Claw Black Cherry Hard Seltzer Menu Categories

Tuesday, January 9th 2024 changes to '50s Prime Time Cafe Lunch/Dinner Menu

Grandma's Picnic Punchdescriptionchanged from Grandma concocted a wonderful drink for the family picnic - SVEDKA Vodka, Peach Schnapps, Crème de Cassis, Minute Maid® Zero Sugar Lemonade, and Pineapple Juiceto Grandma concocted a wonderful drink for the family picnic - SVEDKA Vodka, Bols Peach Schnapps Liqueur, Bols Crème de Cassis Liqueur, Minute Maid® Zero Sugar Lemonade, and Pineapple Juice

Monday, January 1st 2024 changes to '50s Prime Time Cafe Children's Lunch/Dinner Menu

Removed Chicken Noodle Soupfrom Menu Items
Added Creamy Tomato Soupto Menu Items
Added Appetizers/Startersto Creamy Tomato SoupMenu Categories
Added Specialty Beverages (non-alcoholic)to Pomegranate LemonadeMenu Categories

Monday, January 1st 2024 changes to '50s Prime Time Cafe Lunch/Dinner Menu

Beer-Battered Onion Ringscostchanged from 12to 13
A Sampling of Mom's Favorite Recipescostchanged from 28to 30
Flavored Sodascostchanged from 4.99to 5.29
Freshly Brewed Joffrey's Coffee costchanged from to 3.99
Fried Herb and Garlic Cheesecostchanged from 10to 11
Cousin Amy's Iceberg Lettuce Wedgecostchanged from 11to 12
Cousin Megan's Traditional Meatloaf costchanged from 23to 24
Traditional Warm Apple Crispcostchanged from 7.50to 8
Patron Platinum Margaritacostchanged from 16.50to 17
Ultimate Long Island Iced Teacostchanged from 16.50to 17
Dad's Electric Lemonadecostchanged from 16.50to 17
Chocolate Martinicostchanged from 15.50to 16
Fireball Cocktailcostchanged from 14.50to 15
Roasted Tomato Soupnamechanged from Creamy Tomato Soupto Roasted Tomato Soup
Roasted Tomato Soupcostchanged from 9.00to 10
Pineapple Upside-Down Cakecostchanged from to 10
Lemon Meringue Piecostchanged from to 9.5
Grasshopper Barcostchanged from 8.00to 9
Removed Draft Beerfrom Menu Items
Removed Craft Beerfrom Menu Items
Removed Magical Star Cocktailfrom Menu Items
Removed Jalapeño Popper Deviled Eggsfrom Menu Items
Added Deviled Eggsto Menu Items
Added Sustainable Verlasso Salmonto Menu Items
Added Indigo Hibiscusto Menu Items
Added Beerto Menu Items
Added Appetizers/Startersto Deviled EggsMenu Categories
Added Entreesto Sustainable Verlasso SalmonMenu Categories
Added Specialty Cocktailsto Indigo HibiscusMenu Categories
Added Beerto BeerMenu Categories

Tuesday, November 28th 2023 changes to '50s Prime Time Cafe Children's Lunch/Dinner Menu

Removed Tables in Wonderland 20%from Discount Types