REVIEW: This New Magic Kingdom Brownie Is So Nostalgic It May Bring Tears to Your Eyes

When we hear there’s a new snack in Disney World, you can bet we’re already making plans to try it out!

Not only because we want to try it, though that is a large push each time, but it’s also so we can bring you the most honest review so you can decide if it’s worth grabbing on your next vacation. Our most recent adventure took us over to Magic Kingdom where there’s a new brownie at Cosmic Ray’s Starlight Cafe, and it’s so nostalgic, we know it’ll remind LOTS of us of our childhoods!

Unlock the most delectable snacks in Magic Kingdom! Download this guide to ensure every bite of your Disney adventure is pure magic.

Get the Guide

The new Peanut Butter Jelly Brownie is available for $5.99 at Cosmic Ray’s and it’s served with a White Chocolate “Rocket Ship.”

If peanut butter is your thing, you’re going to love this! The peanut butter flavor is so authentic, smooth, and creamy, which we adored. There’s not a lot of jelly flavor, we only tasted it in one or two bites, but the whole thing has a very, very nostalgic flavor.

It’s like if an Uncrustable and a cosmic brownie melted together. The brownie is a little tough and doesn’t really have a lot of texture — it’s more there to provide chocolate flavor and hold the peanut butter mound up, but we didn’t mind that. We would definitely get this again and we think the price is justified due to its uniqueness and its size.

Looking for more recent reviews around the resort? Check out our posts below!

Be sure to stay tuned to AllEars for all the latest Disney snack news and reviews!

REVIEW: This Small Upgrade Completely Changed This Disney World Restaurant, and We’re Here for It

Would you grab this brownie? Tell us in the comments!