Recent Menu Changes to Erin Mckenna’s Bakery NYC All-Day Menu

Monday, March 30th 2026 changes to Erin Mckenna's Bakery NYC All-Day Menu

Donutscostchanged from 5.95to 6.50
Teacakescostchanged from 8.10-$8.65to 9.45
Crumb Cakedescriptionchanged from Cinnamon Crumb Cake, Chocolate Agave Crumb Cake, Blueberry Crumb Caketo Double Chocolate Brown
Crumb Cakecostchanged from 10.80-$11.35to 12.95
Bagelscostchanged from 5.40to 6.95
Bottled Watercostchanged from 4.90to 5.95
Cinnamon Rollcostchanged from 9.70to 12.45
Cookie Sandwichcostchanged from 11.90-$13.50to 13.75-16.45
Hot Teacostchanged from 4.75to 5.45
Coconut Candy Moundscostchanged from 3.25to 5.75
Apple Upside Down Cakenamechanged from Pineapple Upside Downto Apple Upside Down Cake
Apple Upside Down Cakecostchanged from 14.60to 12.95
Bakery Sinkcostchanged from 14.60to 16.95
Dipped Cookie Sandwichcostchanged from 14.30to 16.45
Whoopie Piecostchanged from 10.80to 12.45
Cake Slicescostchanged from 12-$17.30to 14.95
Removed Cupcakesfrom Menu Items
Removed Brownie Cupcakesfrom Menu Items
Removed Brownie Mint Cupcakefrom Menu Items
Removed Brownie Chocolate Cupcakefrom Menu Items
Removed Brownie Raspberry Cupcakefrom Menu Items
Removed Pineapple and Cream Cupcakefrom Menu Items
Removed Hole in One Cupcakefrom Menu Items
Removed Veggie Bombfrom Menu Items
Added Cupcaketo Menu Items
Added Mexican Wedding Cookieto Menu Items
Added Cake Popto Menu Items
Added Dessertto CupcakeMenu Categories
Added Dessertto Mexican Wedding CookieMenu Categories
Added Dessertto Cake PopMenu Categories

Wednesday, January 14th 2026 changes to Erin Mckenna's Bakery NYC All-Day Menu

Thin Mint Sandwichnamechanged from Thicc Mint Sandwichto Thin Mint Sandwich
Added Chocolate Chip Cookieto Menu Items
Added to Menus
Added Dessertto Chocolate Chip CookieMenu Categories

Friday, September 19th 2025 changes to Erin Mckenna's Bakery NYC All-Day Menu

Added 2025 FALL- Pumpkin Teacaketo Menu Items
Added 2025 FALL- Pumpkin Cinnamon Sugar Donutto Menu Items
Added 2025 FALL- Caramel Cinnamon Cupcaketo Menu Items
Added 2025 Fallto 2025 FALL- Pumpkin TeacakeEvents
Added to Image Types
Added 2025 FALL- Pumpkin Teacaketo Menu Items
Added 2025 Fallto 2025 FALL- Pumpkin Cinnamon Sugar DonutEvents
Added to Image Types
Added 2025 FALL- Pumpkin Cinnamon Sugar Donutto Menu Items
Added 2025 Fallto 2025 FALL- Caramel Cinnamon CupcakeEvents
Added to Image Types
Added 2025 FALL- Caramel Cinnamon Cupcaketo Menu Items

Tuesday, August 12th 2025 changes to Erin Mckenna's Bakery NYC All-Day Menu

Added 2025 HALLOWEEN- Bloody Guts Donutto Menu Items
Added 2025 HALLOWEEN- Chocolate Spider Donutto Menu Items
Added 2025 HALLOWEEN- Coffin Caketo Menu Items
Added 2025 HALLOWEEN- Ghost Facesto Menu Items
Added 2025 HALLOWEEN- Mummy Cake Popsto Menu Items
Added 2025 Halloweento 2025 HALLOWEEN- Bloody Guts DonutEvents
Added 2025 Halloweento 2025 HALLOWEEN- Chocolate Spider Donut Events
Added 2025 Halloweento 2025 HALLOWEEN- Coffin CakeEvents
Added 2025 Halloweento 2025 HALLOWEEN- Ghost FacesEvents
Added 2025 Halloweento 2025 HALLOWEEN- Mummy Cake PopsEvents

Saturday, June 21st 2025 changes to Erin Mckenna's Bakery NYC All-Day Menu

Added 2025 FLAVORS OF FLORIDA- Pineapple Upside Down Caketo Menu Items
Added 2025 Flavors of Floridato 2025 FLAVORS OF FLORIDA- Pineapple Upside Down CakeEvents

Thursday, January 9th 2025 changes to Erin Mckenna's Bakery NYC All-Day Menu

Added Churro Cookie Sandwichto Menu Items
Added Dessertto Churro Cookie SandwichMenu Categories

Sunday, November 3rd 2024 changes to Erin Mckenna's Bakery NYC All-Day Menu

Added 2024 HOLIDAYS- Christmas Waffle- Avail 12/2-12/31to Menu Items
Added 2024 HOLIDAYS- Gingerbread Cupcake - Avail 12/2-12/31to Menu Items
Added 2024 Holiday Season WDWto 2024 HOLIDAYS- Christmas Waffle- Avail 12/2-12/31Events
Added 2024 Holiday Season WDWto 2024 HOLIDAYS- Gingerbread Cupcake - Avail 12/2-12/31Events

Monday, October 14th 2024 changes to Erin Mckenna's Bakery NYC All-Day Menu

Removed Cookbooksfrom Menu Items
Removed Hot Chocolatefrom Menu Items
Removed Juice Pouchfrom Menu Items
Removed Iced Teasfrom Menu Items

Thursday, September 12th 2024 changes to Erin Mckenna's Bakery NYC All-Day Menu

Added 2024 HISPANIC & LATIN AMERICAN HERITAGE MONTH- Tres Lechesto Menu Items
Added 2024 HISPANIC & LATIN AMERICAN HERITAGE MONTH- Mexican Wedding Caketo Menu Items
Added 2024 Hispanic & Latin American Heritage Monthto 2024 HISPANIC & LATIN AMERICAN HERITAGE MONTH- Tres LechesEvents
Added 2024 Hispanic & Latin American Heritage Monthto 2024 HISPANIC & LATIN AMERICAN HERITAGE MONTH- Mexican Wedding CakeEvents

Friday, June 28th 2024 changes to Erin Mckenna's Bakery NYC All-Day Menu

Added 2024 FLAVORS OF FLORIDA- Orange Blossom Bomb Cupcaketo Menu Items
Added 2024 FLAVORS OF FLORIDA- Orange Zest Sconesto Menu Items
Added 2024 Flavors of Floridato 2024 FLAVORS OF FLORIDA- Orange Blossom Bomb CupcakeEvents
Added 2024 Flavors of Floridato 2024 FLAVORS OF FLORIDA- Orange Zest SconesEvents

Saturday, June 22nd 2024 changes to Erin Mckenna's Bakery NYC All-Day Menu

Added 2024 PRIDE MONTH- Pride Twinkieto Menu Items
Added 2024 Pride Monthto 2024 PRIDE MONTH- Pride TwinkieEvents

Monday, April 15th 2024 changes to Erin Mckenna's Bakery NYC All-Day Menu

Cupcakesdescriptionchanged from Options vary but may include: Vanilla, Blondie, Brownie, Toastie, Coconut Caramel, Mexican Hot Chocolate; White Mocha, Chocolate Lava, Hot Fudge Pop Tart, Brownie Sunbutter Caramel Eachto Vanilla, Brownie Chocolate, Cookie Monster, Brownie Bomb, Lemon Lavender, Shamrock Shake, Easter Carrot, etc.
Cupcakescostchanged from 6.95-$7.65to 8.10-$9.75
Cookiesdescriptionchanged from Chocolate Chip, Snickerdoodle, Oat Raisin, Ginger, Double Chocolateto
Cookiescostchanged from 3.85to 4.20
Donutsdescriptionchanged from
Cinnamon Sugar, Chocolate Dipped, Samoa, Cookies & Cream, Coffee Crunch, Vanilla Dipped, Strawberry Eachto Vanilla Dipped, Cinnamon Sugar, Blueberry Powdered Sugar, Double Chocolate, etc.
Teacakesdescriptionchanged from Iced lemon, chocolate, banana chocolate chip $42.00 per loaf; eachto Lemon, Marble, Banana, etc. by the slice
Teacakescostchanged from 6.88to 8.10-$8.65
Crumb Cakedescriptionchanged from $62 full; per sliceto Cinnamon Crumb Cake, Chocolate Agave Crumb Cake, Blueberry Crumb Cake
Crumb Cakecostchanged from 9.35to 10.80-$11.35
Bagelsdescriptionchanged from Plain, onion or Everything; includes vegan butter or cream cheese; extra vegan butter or cream cheese $0.75;to Plain, Cinnamon Sugar, Everything
Cookbooksdescriptionchanged from to BabyCakes Cookbook, BabyCakes Covers the Classics, Bread and Butter
Cookbookscostchanged from 24-$28to 27
Hot Chocolatecostchanged from 3.50 / $4.00to 7.45
Ice Cream Cookie Sandwichcostchanged from 16to
Cake Slicescostchanged from 8-$12.50to 12-$17.30
Removed Toppingsfrom Menu Items
Removed Seasonal Specialty Cupcakefrom Menu Items
Removed Savory Biscuitsfrom Menu Items
Removed Cake Barsfrom Menu Items
Removed Sconesfrom Menu Items
Removed Wonderfall/Wonderwinter 4" Cakefrom Menu Items

Tuesday, January 9th 2024 changes to Erin Mckenna's Bakery NYC All-Day Menu

Wonderfall/Wonderwinter 4" Cakenamechanged from Wonderfall 4" Caketo Wonderfall/Wonderwinter 4" Cake

Tuesday, December 19th 2023 changes to Erin Mckenna's Bakery NYC All-Day Menu

Added Veggie Bombto Menu Items
Added to Image Types
Added Brownie Cupcakesto Menu Items
Added Bakeryto Veggie BombMenu Categories
Added to Image Types
Added Veggie Bombto Menu Items
Added to Image Types
Added Dipped Cookie Sandwichto Menu Items
Added to Image Types
Added Cinnamon Rollto Menu Items

Tuesday, September 19th 2023 changes to Erin Mckenna's Bakery NYC All-Day Menu

Coffeecostchanged from 3.99to 4.40
Cinnamon Rollcostchanged from 8.95to 9.70
Pineapple Upside Downcostchanged from 13.50to 14.60
Bakery Sinkcostchanged from 13.50to 14.60
Ice Cream Cookie Sandwichcostchanged from 15to 16
Juice Pouchcostchanged from 3.00to 6.00
Iced Teascostchanged from 5.50to 7.00
Dipped Cookie Sandwichcostchanged from 13.25to 14.30
Decorated 6 inch cakedescriptionchanged from When Available *Wedding Cakes, Birthday Cakes, Specialty Cakes order in advance (Prices starting at $79.20)to When Available *Wedding Cakes, Birthday Cakes, Specialty Cakes order in advance (Prices starting at $88.60)
Savory Biscuitscostchanged from 8.50to 9.20
Dessert Cupscostchanged from 15.50to 16.20
Added Sconesto Menu Items
Added Thicc Mint Sandwichto Menu Items
Added Wonderfall 4" Caketo Menu Items
Added Bakeryto SconesMenu Categories
Added Bakeryto Thicc Mint SandwichMenu Categories
Added Bakeryto Wonderfall 4" CakeMenu Categories