Reviews of Tutto Italia Restaurant – Italy
Read prices, menu items, and more
Menus at Tutto Italia Ristorante
Reviewed by jlundeen Review Date: 01/12/2013
Rating: (1) Not Recommended
We really looked forward to eating here for our Candlelight Dinner before the Processional, as the last trip we had, this place was fantastic.
I wish I could say it was good this time. We were a part of 6 adults, no kids, Deluxe Dining plan. We were seated quickly (a big plus!) and ordered appetizers - I had the Calamari, which was very tasty, but the sauce was filled with red pepper flakes, and they just over-powered the rest.
For dinner, I ordered Spaghetti and Meatballs - now, while I am not Italian, I make home-made Spaghetti and meatballs, using my home grown tomatoes. I was really wanting to try "the real thing", but what I was served was not even close to my sauce. It was VERY bland - like out of a jar from the grocery store. The meatballs, while large, had no flavor at all...very disappointing. For dessert, I ordered Tiramisu...a favorite! It was watery and really lacking in flavor.
When our waiter asked how everything was, I told him the truth, and he looked very pained. He said that the sauce is imported right from Italy... and then apologized profusely, and told me next time we were in Italy, to look him up and he would take us to a place where they had really GOOD Italian food! I might just have to do that!
The tables in this restaurant are VERY close together, and the wait stations are almost in your lap.
I don't think we'll be back.
Pros:
seated quicklyCons:
a total disappointmentReviewed by allec999 Review Date: 03/22/2024
Rating: (8) Recommended
Solid Italian food, good service. A great choice if you have picky eaters. A nice wine list to go with solid entrees. Overall, a good experience.
Pros:
Food, service, wineCons:
noneReviewed by Anonymous Review Date: 02/14/2023
Rating: (10) Recommended
Micah was the best server, and they had a great gluten free selection!
Pros:
Micah’s serviceCons:
N/aReviewed by Anonymous Review Date: 04/06/2021
Rating: (9) Recommended
Me and my family went here on our most recent trip and it was just about amazing. The service and food was amazing, and the whole aesthetic of it was truly astonishing. Our waiter was very kind, and was from Italy. The only thing is, there isn't a lot of options on the menu. Otherwise I would say, it might be my favorite italian restaurant in Walt Disney World.
Pros:
Great food, amazing service, breathtaking atmosphere.Cons:
Not a lot of food options.Reviewed by 45stoutjay Review Date: 04/06/2020
Rating: (7) Recommended
This is okay, not the best place Italian restaurant in Disney World. The menu is very small and does not chicken parm, which is always my go-to.
Pros:
Service and the food I had was good, but not greatCons:
Limited menuReviewed by debweb218 Review Date: 03/17/2020
Rating: (10) Recommended
We love the steak here! Mmm! And the best tea in all of Disney world!
Pros:
Iced teaCons:
Salad is extra priceReviewed by tiffynicole1984 Review Date: 01/04/2020
Rating: (8) Recommended
Very hard to get a reservation here. Both this year and last the restaurant was hardly filled. I don't understand this? Nevertheless the food here is very good if you like Italian. If you want something "lighter" I had the salmon which was very good. We had dinner here Thursday 12/05/19. At first I was upset I couldn't get a reservation for any time other than 9pm but it was so nice leaving an empty Epcot with not worrying about a huge line for the bus back to the hotel. For two adults on deluxe dining plan $136.59.
Pros:
Very good authentic Italian food and serviceCons:
Very expensive if not on dining plan, very hard to get a reservation - yet they don't fill the restaurant?Reviewed by tdischer Review Date: 08/11/2019
Rating: (8) Recommended
Was very good food, great atmosphere, brought us birthday cupcakes, beautiful restaurant.
Pros:
desserts were great!Cons:
Wouldn't let my son substitute any of the sides (he's 13, didn't want the vegetable or the potato offered) but it worked out fine. Waiter was not overly friendly, but was very good and efficient.Reviewed by debg33 Review Date: 06/09/2019
Rating: (10) Recommended
The last night of our trip we always have dinner here. It is a great way to finish off our trip. The service and food here is always spot on. I highly recommend the eggplant,lasagna and sangria. Never disappointing. Highly recommend.
Pros:
EverythingCons:
NothingReviewed by lauridg Review Date: 05/26/2019
Rating: (7) Recommended
We always try to eat somewhere we have not yet tried, and this trip, we decided to try Tutto Italia. The staff was very pleasant and attentive, without being overbearing. I had the lobster ravioli, which was pretty good. It wasn't anything amazing either, but I enjoyed it. My husband had an eggplant dish, and he enjoyed that. We opted for the salad instead of a dessert since we were on the dining plan, and the salad was very good. It was definitely a one time place, I don't feel a need to go back, but I am glad we tried it.
