Reviews of Cape May Cafe Clam Bake Dinner
Read prices, menu items, and more
Menus at Cape May Cafe
Reviewed by Topdawg101 Review Date: 02/08/2021
Rating: (10) Recommended
My absolute favorite place! Hello.... All you can eat crab legs and other seafood? The deserts were good and the variety is awesome.
Pros:
Variety. Crab legs.Cons:
Not currently openReviewed by Sheri10s Review Date: 04/14/2020
Rating: (6) Recommended
Just Mediocre
Pros:
Crab Legs-I recommend going once.Cons:
Too crowdedReviewed by skipperina Review Date: 03/18/2020
Rating: (9) Recommended
We really loved this restaurant. If you love snow crabs, this is the place for you.
Pros:
Good service, snow crabs!, good variety, tons of desserts, fun location to visitCons:
Not a ton of variety for non-seafood eaters, bathrooms are in a weird locationReviewed by Bubbe415 Review Date: 06/19/2019
Rating: (8) Recommended
We are staying in Sarasota and made a special trip for a couple of nights just to go to cape may! love the crab legs! and service is always good. Desserts are interesting - not the thing you go for but they are good.
Pros:
Crab legs. Service. ambiance.Cons:
rest of food is good but not outstanding. but worth the tripReviewed by Anonymous Review Date: 04/28/2019
Rating: (10) Recommended
Everything is good great service .
Pros:
EverythingCons:
NothingReviewed by Teresab715 Review Date: 04/20/2019
Rating: (9) Recommended
Great food options for the seafood lover or anyone
Pros:
Love the mussels and the crab legs - yum! I also enjoyed the coffee crusted prime rib and salmon. There is nothing like this anywhere else on property. Probably one of my top 5 favorite restaurants on property.Cons:
If seafood is not your thing - you may not like this restaurant, however there are non-seafood choices - but let's be real - you go for the seafood.Reviewed by Stitch1623 Review Date: 04/18/2019
Rating: (8) Recommended
We have eaten here a few times. Staff is friendly. Drinks are great. The meat eaters in my group likes the meat selections every time we went. Nice selection of crab, clams and shrimp as well as kids items. The last time we went in 2018 there was a wider variety of dessert items which we were please about. My only complaint is the breads are always hard and seem a bit stale and the side items like vegetables and noodles/rice dishes could have a larger selection. Overall, we like this buffet when compared to the many others in Disney.
Pros:
All you can eat crab/seafood, usually not crowdedCons:
Needs more selectionsReviewed by Oscar Review Date: 07/04/2018
Rating: (5) Recommended
Surprised to find huge platters of watermelon chunks and cantaloupe chunks where salads and cheeses used to be. Cheese is almost non-existent and very low quality. A huge part of the buffet area is covered with various types of breads -- cornbread was extremely dry -- which has pushed the carving station into a very small corner. The side dishes were very poor quality, casserole style, and mostly tasteless.The waitress indicated that they had made major changes two weeks ago. A different type of crab legs were also served. Hard to crack open. Regular crab legs were still good. Obviously, changes were not made to please customers, they were made to make more money.
Pros:
All You Care to Eat Crab LegsCons:
Changes in the menu and the preparationReviewed by jannielane Review Date: 03/27/2018
Rating: (8) Recommended
Cape May no longer offers the wide selection of foods every day that it used to offer, so check to make sure that they are serving what you want before making reservations. That said, the food is well prepared and plentiful. I tend to stick with crab legs, shrimp, any other shellfish, salads and vegetables, and have no reason to complain. Fin fish tends to be overcooked and ordinary. I've never tried any of the meat selections. Desserts are ordinary. This is not fine dining, but if you like unlimited seafood, it's a treat.
Be prepared for lots of little kids running all over the place. The restaurant was not all that loud, but kids really were running and not watching who they crashed into.
Pros:
Well prepared foodCons:
Selection is reduced from past visitsReviewed by The Papi Review Date: 02/25/2018
Rating: (7) Recommended
Maybe it was an "off" night, but the crab legs had very little meat and were extremely difficult to crack open. The shells were somewhat soft. It was all just OK, which is fine if you're on a free dining plan. But for us paying out of pocket, the value just wasn't there. We aren't huge eaters, so we did not feel we got our moneys worth. Disappointing because we loved this place in the past. 🙁
