Olivia's Cafe
Old Key West - Resort
Dinner Menu


Menu Date: May 2017

Reader Rating:

View Reader Reviews | Share Your Review

Show All Food Photos

Discounts Available:

-- Annual Passholder 20%
-- Disney Rewards VISA 10%
-- Disney Vacation Club 10%
-- Tables in Wonderland 20%

Disney Dining Plan:

-- Table Service Meal (2017)


Lump Crab Cakes - avocado puree and fresh mango salsa $13

Conch Fritters - with Key Lime-Mustard and Remoulade $12

Homemade Soup of the Day - ask your server for details $7

Olivia's House Salad - Mixed Greens with Seasonal Accompaniments and a House-made Vinaigrette $7

Tomato-Mozzarella Salad - with Mixed Greens and Balsamic glaze $10

Onion Rings - with Mango Ketchup and Key Lime-Mustard $7

Conch Chowder - Manhatten-style served with oyster crackers $8

Caesar Salad - Romaine Lettuce with Parmesan and Croutons; add chicken for $6; $9


Grilled New York Strip - served with mashed potatoes, asparagus and mushrooms, tomatoes, and onion ragout $33

Island Barbecue Pork Ribs - spicy Chipotle-Barbecue Sauce with French Fries and Marinated Coleslaw $23

Seven Mile Sea Scallops - Mascarpone and prosciutto Polenta, asparagus and Tomato vinaigrette $26

Duval Street Burger - topped with Grilled Shrimp, Pepper Jack Cheese, Avocado, and Pico de Gallo on a Pineapple-Coconut Roll $18

Southernmost Buttermilk Chicken - mashed potatoes, southern gravy, and seasonal vegetables $18

Mahi Mahi - crab-crusted mahi mahi served with a tropical couscous, avocado, pico de gallo, and mango butter $24

Caribbean Tofu and Rice - sauteed tofu with red bell peppers, plantains, mushrooms, and pineapple served over coconut rice; add shrimp $23; $19

Slow-Cooked Prime Rib - 10-oz cut with Olivia's potatoes, seasonal vegetables and cabernet demi-glace $32

Mallory Square Cobb Salad - Romaine Lettuce with layers of Chilled Shrimp, Crab Salad, Bacon, Egg, Blue Cheese, Tomato, and Avocado with a Key-Lime Mustard Vinaigrette $19

Plantation Key Pork Chop - brined bone-in pork chop glazed with an apple-white balsamic gastrique severed with purple sweet potatoes, apples, onions, brussels sprouts, and tossed in a bacon vinaigrette $24

Cayo Hueso Shrimp Pasta - sauteed shrimp, Roasted Peppers, Grape Tomatoes, crushed red pepper and Arugula tossed with a fettuccine pasta Tomato Broth $23


Mascarpone Cheesecake - with Seasonal Fruit $8

Flourless Chocolate Cake - with fresh seasonal berries $8

Key Lime Tart - with mango and raspberry sauce $7

Banana Bread Pudding Sundae - served warm with Bananas Foster topping and Vanilla Bean Ice Cream $7

Mile Marker Zero - No Sugar Added Tropical Panna Cotta $8


Soft Drinks - Coke, diet Coke, Coke Zero, Sprite, Root beer, Pibb Xtra, Light Pomegranate Lemonade $3.19

Iced Tea $3.19

Hot Tea $2.99


French Press Pot Estate Grown Organic Colombian Joffrey's Coffee - serves two $8

Coffee $2.99

Espresso $3.69

Cappuccino or Latte $4.39

Cafe Mocha $4.69

Frozen Cappuccino $5.50

Specialty Beverages (non-alcoholic)

Milk Shakes - chocolate, vanilla, or strawberry $5.5

Disney Character Punch - Light Lemonade Punch served in a souvenir cup with a glowing Disney character clip-on light $7

Specialty Cocktails

Magical Star Cocktail - X-Fusion Organic Mango and Passion Fruit Liqueur, Parrot Bay Coconut Rum, Pineapple Juice, and a souvenir Multicolored Glow Cube $12

Sultry Seahorse - Disaronno Originale, Creme de Banana, Pineapple Juice, Orange Juice, and a float of Cherry Brandy $9.75

Captain's Mai Tai - Captain Morgan Original Spiced rum, Amaretto, and tropical juices topped with a float of Myers's Original dark rum $10

Turtle Krawl - Siesta Key White Rum, Parrot Bay Coconut Rum, and Sailor Jerry Spiced Rum with grenadine, Pineapple, Orange, and Key Lime Juices $9.75

Rum Runner - Myers's Original Dark Rum, Creme de Banana, Blackberry Brandy, and Orange and Pineapple Juices with a float of Bacardi 151 Rum $9.75

Godiva Chocolate Martini - Godiva chocolate liqueur, Stoli vanil vodka, white creme de cacao, and frangelico $10.75

Banana Spiced Rum Martini - RumChata, Captain Morgan, creme de banana $9.75

Key Lime Pie Martini - Stoli vanil vodka, LICOR 43, lime juice, and vanilla ice cream $10.75

Irish Coffee - with Jameson Irish whiskey $9.5

Jamaican Coffee - with Tia Maria and rum $9.75

Italian Coffee - with amaretto $9.5

Keoki Coffee - with Kahlua and brandy $9.5


Key West Sunset Ale - draft $6.75

Yeungling Lager - draft $6.75

Samuel Adams Seasonal - draft $6.75

Bud Light - draft $6.00

Import/Specialty Bottled Beer - Corona or Blue Moon $6.50

Premium Bottled Beer - New Belgium Fat Tire, New Belgium Ranger, Key West Southernmost Wheat, 7 Mile IPA, Schofferhoffer Hefeweizen, Stella Artois, Angry Orchard Crisp Apple Hard Cider or Guinness Stout $7.50-$8.75


Assorted White Wines - by the glass $9 - $14; by the bottle $39 - $59

Assorted Red Wines - by the glass $9 - $13; by the bottle $39 - $55

Sparkling Wine - by the glass $9; by the bottle $39

Sangria - Beso del Sol red or white, by the glass $9.5


Return to Dining Location: Olivia's Cafe

Return to Dining Location Index