Ranking the Evilness of the Disney Villains

We were so excited earlier this week when Disney World announced a special, ticketed evening event starting this June — Villains After Hours! It’s a three-hour event in Magic Kingdom after regular operating hours, featuring the Villains in a new stage show, with other special treats throughout the night.

©Disney

That got us to thinking… of course, all of the Disney Villains are evil, but who’s the worst of the worst, the baddest of the bad, the meanest of the mean?

That’s precisely what we are here to discuss! We’ve taken a look at the most popular villains and ranked them from Least Evil to Most Evil. We dove deep into motives, crimes committed, and general not-niceness to create our rankings. Here  are the results:

19. Prince John

 

Image result for prince john disney gif
©Disney

Sure, taxing the poor village people an obscene amount isn’t exactly kind — but look at the guy? Not exactly the stuff of evil.

18. Queen of Hearts

 

Image result for queen of hearts disney gif
©Disney

We get that she has a bad temper and possibly overreacts to the color of flowers, but at the end of the day, she’s just a part of a very odd dream. Higher rankings are reserved for villains that are more than just in our heroine’s head.

17. Captain Hook

 

Related image
©Disney

He loses points for trapping Tinker Bell, but any villain who can be outsmarted by a croc with a clock doesn’t deserve a very high spot on our list.

16. Shere Khan

 

Related image
©Disney

Yes, he tries to kill Mowgli. But… he’s a tiger. Can you really blame him?

15. Governor Ratcliffe 

 

Image result for ratcliffe disney gif
©Disney

He does try to start a war, but honestly, wouldn’t you be a little bit miffed if you expected to find mounds of gold and you only found corn?

14. Lady Tremaine

 

Related image
©Disney

The fact that she didn’t actually murder anyone is the only reason she isn’t higher on our list (the bar isn’t very high). Imprisoning your stepdaughter and turning her into a slave is pretty darn evil.

13. Hades

 

Image result for hades disney gif
©Disney

Sure, being Lord of the Underworld doesn’t sound like the best job in the universe, but is that an excuse to kidnap and attempt to murder a baby? No, we didn’t think so.

12. Ursula

 

Related image
©Disney

Is it nice to trick a mermaid into turning into a human to attempt to win over a man she saw for 45 minutes? No. But did Ariel deserve it? Well, kinda…

11. Gaston

 

Image result for gaston disney gif
©Disney

Sure, he easily persuaded a mob of people to march on a castle for his own selfish means. But also, he’s a hunter and he was just… hunting. That said, we weren’t sad to see him go.

10. Jafar

 

Image result for jafardisney gif
©Disney

To be fair, Aladdin was lying about who he was. But did he deserve to be sent to the arctic tundra in just a vest? Probably not. Besides, Jafar is ruthlessly trying to take over a kingdom at any cost, and that’s just not cool.

9. Dr. Facilier

 

Image result for dr facilier disney gif
©Disney

Truth be told, this guy scares the bejesus out of us. He’s got actual voodoo magic and evil spirits on his side! The only reason he isn’t higher on our list is because he doesn’t actually murder Naveen (but we can’t forgive him for Ray!), though he does plot it in his attempts to take over New Orleans.

8. Mother Gothel

 

Image result for mother gothel disney gif
©Disney

Does Mother Gothel murder anyone? No. Does Mother Gothel have an evil plot to take over a kingdom? No. But is Mother Gothel terrifying? YES.

Emotional manipulation is no joke, friends! Plus, there’s the whole stealing a baby so you can remain young forever thing.

7. Hans

Image result for hans disney gif
©Disney

Hans is just your typical Disney prince, minus the whole “pretending to be in love with a princess so he can leave her to die and murder her sister and take over the kingdom” thing.

We know you had 12 brothers, Hans, but yeesh.

6. Cruella de Vil

 

Image result for cruella disney gif
©Disney

She wants to murder a bunch of puppies for a coat. MURDER. PUPPIES. Need we say more?

Oh, but also, her name is literally CRUEL DEVIL.

5. Shan Yu

 

Image result for shan yu disney gif
©Disney

He burns an entire village, including children, to the ground. Even in a war (that he started), that’s very evil.

4. Maleficent

 

Image result for maleficent disney gif
©Disney

She calls everyone fools and puts a murderous curse on an infant because she wasn’t invited to a party. Petty? Perhaps. But she’s not called the “Mistress of all Evil” for nothing.

3. The Evil Queen

 

Related image
©Disney

She puts a hit out on her 13-year-old step-daughter because she thinks the girl is prettier than she is. And not only that, she demands to see the dead girl’s heart in a box. YIKES.

The Evil Queen is the OG Disney Villain, and she’s still one of the baddest.

2. Scar

 

Related image
©Disney

Scar murders his brother in cold blood, in front of his nephew, and then uses psychological manipulation to make his nephew believe he’s responsible for his dad’s death. Yep… that’s evil all right.

1. Judge Claude Frollo

 

Related image
©Disney

When it comes to evil, Frollo has done it all!

Murder a woman? Check.

Attempt to murder her innocent baby? Check.

Imprison the baby for the foreseeable future? Check.

Psychologically torture the boy? You betcha!

Attempt to destroy an entire population? Of course!

Attempt to murder the boy again? Why not!

Frollo is the creme de la creme when it comes to evil. His laundry list of meanness covers everything from manipulation to attempted genocide. For these reasons, he tops our list as the worst of the worst — the most evil of all the Disney villains. Not a crown we’d be proud of.

So there you have our rankings of the Disney villains, from least to most evil. What do you think — did we get it right? Let us know in the comments!

 

And don’t forget to check the details on Villains After Hours, starting this June in the Magic Kingdom!

Be sure to check out our YouTube Channel for reviews, news, information and more! 

Subscribe to the AllEars® newsletter so you don’t miss any of the latest Disney news!

Click here to subscribe

 

Molly is a lifelong Disney enthusiast, and former Walt Disney World Guest Relations Cast Member and tour guide. Her Walt Disney World favorites include Festival of the Lion King, Big Thunder Mountain Railroad, Fantasmic!, Mickey-shaped pretzels and rice krispie treats, and anything with Buzz Lightyear! She lives in Orlando with her husband (who she met in Guest Relations) and their two rescue dogs, Kronk and Cruella de Vil (Ella for short!)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

10 Replies to “Ranking the Evilness of the Disney Villains”

  1. Totally agree with 1 and 2. I feel Lady Tremaine should have been in the top 5 and the Coachman from Pinnochio should have been up there too. My top 5, in no particular order would be Judge Claude Frollo, Scar, Lady Tremaine, the Coachman from Pinnochio, and Cruella DeVill

  2. I appreciate the great try on this, but I feel you missed number one, the Coachman from Pinocchio. He kidnaps young boys, traps them on his island, gives them cigars and beer, rips off their clothes, then sells them into slavery only after they have lost the ability to speak anymore. If they are not fully “donkeys” left and beg for their lives, he cages them until it is so. AND, he never gets caught at the end of the movie…terrifying for young children..

  3. Missing some villains: The Horned King (we never see it but he’s definitely killed people), Chernobog (didn’t kill but demons), and the Hunter who killed Bambi’s mother often makes it on to lists of worst villains. The coachman from Pleasure Island, even if the boys deserved it, was scary and cruel. Ratigan, McLeach, and the Headless Horseman are pretty memorable as well.

  4. I think Madam Medusa really deserves a place on this list. She is scary because she is someone who could really exist. Her terror doesn’t come from magic, but from doing something that happens in real life – kidnaping children.

      1. Yes, totally agree with this one!
        Mother Gothel has that same vanity driven, no redeeming qualities whatsoever personality. And, technically, she did murder Flynn, just to show the length she would go to in order to break Rapunzel. To me, she should be higher on the list.

  5. Hold on…wait just one magical minute…Dr. Facilier doesn’t murder anyone? He steps on Ray the firefly!! Does that not count as murder because he’s an insect?